Mayberry Malt & Coffee Shoppe
Welcome to Mayberry Malt & Coffee Shoppe, a charming café situated at 709 Front St, Clay City, IN 47841, where the essence of a classic American ice cream parlor meets the warmth of a cozy coffee shop. This delightful hidden gem is the kind of place that invites you to slow down, unwind, and indulge in nostalgic flavors, perfect for all ages.
As you step inside, the air is filled with the sweet aroma of freshly brewed coffee and the rich, creamy scents of decadent ice cream delights. The atmosphere is both welcoming and cheerful, with the option to enjoy your treats in the quaint indoor space or bask in the sunshine on the outdoor patio during warmer months—a perfect spot to sip on a milkshake and reminisce about carefree days.
Speaking of milkshakes, the star of the show here is undoubtedly their hand-dipped ice cream selections. Customers rave about the thickness and flavor of the shakes, with Schmoo Smith noting they had to wait for their deliciously thick shake to melt just enough to sip! The café's offerings range from classic favorites to innovative concoctions, ensuring there's something for everyone. Jennifer Key and Andy Jennings both praised the variety and quality of the ice cream, noting the friendly service and pleasant dining experience.
Beyond just ice cream, Mayberry Malt & Coffee Shoppe also specializes in delicious coffee and an array of sweet treats, perfect for satisfying that afternoon craving. The accommodating staff, as described by Bethany Schunk, ensures your visit is not only delightful but also quick, making every sweet moment count.
Every scoop tells a story and every sip brings back memories. As testaments from satisfied patrons like Steve Pressnell and Megan Heller reflect, this café has won the hearts of many who find joy in a simple visit for ice cream or a coffee pick-me-up. Whether you're reminiscing about childhood memories or making new ones with family and friends, Mayberry Malt & Coffee Shoppe is a celebratory spot worthy of your time.
So, come visit this delightful café, indulge in a scoop of your favorite ice cream or a perfectly brewed cup of coffee, and experience the unique charm Mayberry has to offer. Trust us, once you step through those doors, you’ll understand why so many locals and travelers alike are enamored with this sweet sanctuary.
For more information or to plan your visit, give them a call at +1 812-939-3200. Explore the flavors that await you!
95 Reviews
16 Sep 2025
13 Sep 2025
05 Aug 2025
27 Jul 2025
15 Jul 2025
26 Jun 2025
22 Jun 2025
Loft Café Lounge
The Cosy Cafe Hinckley
Mondocialde
Cafetería La Saranda Tropical
Caffetteria La Stretta
Join the Mayberry Malt & Coffee Shoppe Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.